Note: This is a three column page; actually all the pages here are three columns wide. If third column is not appearing for you, please just stetch your browser's view of the document to its full width and they should all show fine. There is a surprising disparity in appearance from different screens and different browsers!

ARTICLE DIRECTORY


Things are not as they seem ... Nor are they otherwise

THE BUTTON!

THE BUTTON!
Warning: Press at Your Peril - Thoughts and Ideas Inside!
Showing posts with label pollution. Show all posts
Showing posts with label pollution. Show all posts

25.12.08

Exxon: Pouring Oil on Trouble Waters -- Part 7



December 25, 2008
[Update February 15, 2009]

Exxon: Pouring Oil on Troubled Waters - Part 7
-AKA-
The After Math


There is much much more to the "aftermath" than just the financial aspects. It affects the entire state in so many ways. Even in just the financial realm, the economic "ripple" effect multiplies the damage done to us by the Supreme Court manyfold. We won't even be able to guess at some of the effects; indeed, some probably won't show themselves for years. But we'll cover the primary damages and take a shot at showing some of the ripples.

Doing the (after)math isn't very difficult. The jury awarded the 32,000 Exxon plaintiffs $5 billion in punitive damages to be divided amongst them (the 32,000 plaintiffs) by arcane formulas, but which averaged out to just a little over $150,000 each.

$5 billion / 32,000 = $156,250.

That sounds like a great deal of money, but commercial fishing is a serious, expensive, business. A fully equipped salmon fishing boat can easily cost more than that amount. Gillnets, crab and shrimp pots, long-line gear ... whatever the fishery there is specialized and expensive equipment that must be purchased. So must an ever-increasing amount of electronics (for example, the Fish and Game may open a specific area for fishing ... in order to know for sure that you are in the legal area you used to need a radar and a loran. Those are still used, but now GPS systems are virtual requirements. Then one must have a plethora of communications gear ... often radio systems have special channel crystals so only people within that fishing group can hear the conversation (fishermen often form small groups that work together to find the fish), plus one must have a CB radio since many still talk on those and you need to hear if there is a fish call somewhere, and now, of course, satellite phones are becoming "de rigor" (since much fishing occurs outside the range of cell phones).

Then, in addition to all the "stuff" it takes to actually fish ... one must have a permit to be allowed to do so. The permits in different fisheries vary in price ... and within a fishery vary from year to year as fishing income ebbs and flows. But I have seen fishing permits sell for substantially over 1/2 million dollars. As in $500,000+. Then a captain has to hire a crew ... and buy fuel and ... well, the point is, one must catch a lot of fish just to "break even" and that in the context of the size of the businesses that we are dealing with, $150,000 isn't really much money. I've seen a single herring seine "set" catch well over $150,000 of fish in one "seine-full".

But, on appeal, the 9th Circuit said that was too much and sent it back to Judge Holland who reduced it by a billion and sent it back.

$5 billion - $1 billion = $4 billion.

As someone famously said, "A billion here, a billion there ... pretty soon you're talking real money!" The plaintiff had just had "a billion" taken from them. It was theirs. It wasn't a future possibility of a billion. The jury had awarded it and the Judge had signed the Judgment. That Judgment is a piece of commercial paper much like a promissory note and can be bought and sold. I know of over a dozen sales that plaintiffs made of part of their Judgment (at a discount since the "promissory note" wasn't technically due until the appeals were denied or the 30 day appeal period ran out, and they were desperate for the money that was being withheld from them).

Even that isn't precisely correct; which is always a problem with analogies. The Judgment was due. Generally, to mount an appeal a losing defendant must post a bond or put up cash in the amount of the Judgment which is held in trust for the plaintiffs while the defendant's case is appealed. So the Judgment was due and the money to pay it literally "sitting there". It is just that there was a "hold" placed on the actual payment during the appeal process.

Then after it had been batted about a bit (back to Judge Holland who refused to be part of the scullduggery; back to the appellate court) the 9th Circuit reduced it another $1.5 billion.

$4 billion - $1.5 billion = $2.5 billion.

The incredible shrinking judgment was the wool sweater that was too tight before someone washed it in hot water! And the washing continued.

The U.S. Supreme Court, packed full of Justices who likely make up the lowest total I.Q. of any Supreme Court since we went to nine Justices, blithely ignored the Constitution and common sense (as well as common law), in order to keep the rabble (that's us) from dipping their hands in the king's (that is the giant corporations and insurance companies) treasure chest (a few days worth of Exxon's net income). In a Decision which will eventually be one that is taught heavily in law schools everywhere, they gutted the jury and it's award and knocked the award down nearly another $2 billion!

$2.5 billion -$2 billion = $500 million dollars.

Although it hardly matters, the actual exact number that the Court pulled out of its ... thin air ... was $507.5 million.

Even before the courts slashed the claim like a backstreet hoodlum slicing a throat ... it was too low. What we didn't know in 1989 at the time of the spill ... nor even in 1994 at the time of the trial ... is that 20 years after the spill there are still fisheries in PWS that have not reopened because they haven't recovered from Exxon's destruction of them. As a result, there are fishermen who have not been able to pursue their livelihood for 20 years and, by now, probably never will.

So not only did they lose 20+ years of their livelihood and the culture and lifestyle that went with it (acquired by some just by growing up there; but by others at tremendous personal cost and trauma ... there were midwest farmboys and New York city slickers who had given their all to chase a dream. And that particular dream is a rough one to chase! A dream that turned into a nightmare for all (Exxcept ... the misspelling is intentional ... for Exxon who is loudly gloating at the Christmas present the Supreme's gave them!)

Other aftermaths. Let's see. What did the government do? Alaska has a lot of leverage with Exxon and the oil companies. So, did they lend some muscle to convince Exxon to pay the money the jury told it to pay and not wait until all the claimants were dead? Of course not. They got involved all right. Governments are good at getting involved when they should probably just go away. But they had less ideas on how to clean up an oil spill than New Orleans did about how to deal with a flood! And the feds were totally useless. The State got some cleanup money from Exxon (of course the courts did not take away ... it was only the little guy that the courts decided to kick while they were already down!) Wait! I was talking about the United States of America Federal Court system ... and I used the definition of a bully. Hmm.




Naturally, the cleanup money was largely wasted and, in fact, the entire cleanup was a fiasco (see earlier articles in the series) that almost assuredly did more harm than good (except for P.R. -- both the State and Exxon needed the big cleanup project for P.R. purposes.) But let's be honest. The only thing they were really trying to clean up were their reputations. It was critical to seem to be doing something about it; even if they had no idea what to do. So they washed oiled rocks with scalding hot water, killing off all the microorganisms that had managed to survive the oil itself and which, if they'd been left alone, would have formed the foundation for new growth and recovery. Nature has been at this game a lot longer than man. It has been cleaning up natural oil "spills" and other environmental disasters for a very long time.




But anyway, we got some shiny new taxes (whee) and a whole bunch of "the horse is gone so lets get that barn door closed really good" regulations.




We should finish the math. As mentioned, each fishery and other affected groups of plaintiffs are allocated different percentages of the total recovery and within each group each individual's "claim percentage" differs based on arcane formulas (one of the primary criteria being a person's fishing history compared with others in his or her fishery ... the "highliners" get the biggest percentages. So the "average" that we calculate may well not match anyone's actual check, but we had approximately 32,000 plaintiffs and the Supreme Court determined that the maximum amount of total punitive damages that could be awarded was $507.5 million. (There is a possibility that the plaintiffs will get interest on that ... but Exxon has filed a motion with the 9th Circuit to bar any liability for interest ... despite the fact that it has been ~20 years since the spill and ~15 years since the judgment. And despite the fact that it was Exxon that was the primary cause of the delays. Given, however, that the appelate courts seem willing to do Exxon's bidding no matter how absurd, no one is counting on receiving interest.)




But we're doing math here. The way the Supreme court worded the opinion such that it was arguable that the 9th Circuit had the authority to reduce the award even further. Given that, even if they tried and failed, it would presumably add many more months (at least) to the point where any money actually got distributed. So ... the plaintiff attorneys, already ruined financially and emotionally, settled for 75% of the Supreme Court's imaginary number.




$507.5 million x .75 = $380.625 million




Whee. The 32,000 of us will get over $380 million. But my math is off for some reason. I'm not sure why, but it appears that the settlement number was closer to $383 million. And they now count the plaintiff group at approximately 33,000 people. Given the numbers we're working with, that change is de minimus and not worth tracking down (this from a man who was, briefly, an accountant in an "earlier life" - actually the first year or two after undergraduate school). But see:




$380 million / 32,000 = $11,875.00




$383 million / 33,000 = $11,606.06




For simplicity sake, let's roughly split the difference and figure the average "take" for a plaintiff is $11,740.




"Well," you might think, "it is better than a poke in the eye with a sharp stick and at least it averaged over $10,000 per person!"




Virtually none of the plaintiffs would agree. After spending 20 years anticipating that the average would be about a decimal point farther to the right (somewhat oddly, the interest the judgment was accruing kept the total award fairly close to the original $5 billion even as it kept getting reduced ... until the Supremes got their hands on it), $10,000 is ... pathetic. Even if the courts decide to award interest (don't hold your breath) it won't be significant given the 20 years of waiting and clinging to the ledge by fingernails.




Our lawyers did a superb job, it wasn't they that ... oh. Right. Can't forget that part.




Although they may well have been legally entitled to more given the original contingency contracts that were signed with the fishermen a couple decades ago, the lawyers settled for 20% of the award for attorney fees.




Which means that the average plaintiff received (or will receive) ~80% of the $11,740.




$11,740 x .8 = $9,392. By the rules of grammar and sentence construction it is discretionary whether one uses a comma when between $1000 and $9999. If you had suggested to anyone fifteen years ago that the checks to the individual fishermen would not require a comma, it would have been believed to be extremely ignorant and pessimistic.




But we're not done. We have to go back and fix a "mistake" I made.




The $380 / $383 [hereinafter averaged to $381.5] million dollar number is wrong.




Several years ago a secret deal came to light; one that Exxon had cut with the only substantive sized companies in the plaintiff class (it appears that it was only the individuals and very small businesses that Exxon wasn't willing to settle with and vowed to "whup"). They didn't have any problem cutting what was characterized as an "under the table" deal with the fish processors.




There were seven of them and they were based in Seattle so ended up being known as the Seattle Seven. The deal was cut in 1991, long before verdict in the 1994 trial and in such a manner that the processors agreed not to say anything and to remain as nominal plaintiffs in the legal action but to pay Exxon their share of the judgment (or at least the punitive damages part) if any were forthcoming. When this deal was discovered, the plaintiff attorneys screamed loudly and Judge Holland was not happy. Essentially no lawyer or judge had ever run into a situation such as that. A plaintiff who had already settled with the defendant ... with an agreement to pay the defendant whatever the plaintiff was awarded! It was a real head-scratcher. But the courts eventually ruled that it was lawful (essentially they couldn't find anything that said it wasn't because it was so unusual and strange!)




As a result we have the bizarre situation that of the $383 million, Exxon will, in effect, pay itself $54 million of that ... which for our purposes is the same as not paying it.




$381.5 million - $54 million = $327.5 million.




So, we must do our math again. We'll use an average of 32,500 plaintiffs.




$327.5 million /32,500 = $10,077.




Then we still must take care of the attorneys, so




$10,077 x .80 = $8,062.




That's the thing with whittling. It really doesn't matter how big a stick you start with .... what matters is how much of it you whittle off.




And when you stop whittling. "No!" you say. "They couldn't have reduced any farther." Well, they didn't ... exactly. Not in that case.




In an earlier bout of shafting of the populace in Commissioner v. Glenshaw Glass Co., 348 U.S. 426 (1955) [believe it or not there are many Supreme Court decisions with which I agree :-)], the Supreme Court reviewed two cases in the process of determining that punitive damages were indeed taxable.




So ... even though they closed up their special "Exxon claim offices" in Anchorage, the I.R.S. is still going to get every drop of blood it can.




Really rough numbers ... I would take a wild guess (certainly not as wild a guess as the Supreme Court did regarding punitive damages percentages but ... :-) that a "reasonable estimate" is that most fisherfolk probably fall somewhere near the 25% marginal tax bracket [ie: from whatever their income would have been in 2008 absent Exxon payments, the "next dollar" would be taxed at the rate of 25%]. That is where a single person earning between $32,551 and $78,850 would fall.




[Note: Lisa Murkowski, Alaska's "appointed by Dad" U.S. Senator did manage to (barely) wrangle some minor tax relief for us. Essentially, we get to income average the money from Exxon ... no, not over 20 years which might make sense, but over 3 years. The way it is paying out in dribbles it may well end up spread over three years anyway. The bill also contains a provision that allows recipients to put up to $100,000 of it into an IRA. The bill was drafted back when people expected there was going to be real money involved (and was only passed because it was piggy backed onto the emergency financing bailout package at the last minute). The thought that most claims are going to be small enough that they could be put entirely into an IRA was not contemplated at the time the bill was drafted!




However. The three year income averaging won't change my rough cut 25% estimate anyway ... and if any of the claimants are in an economic position where they can just set the funds away for retirement ... aren't the claimants I'm concerned about anyway (and there aren't many of them). It is almost funny if one is truly into gallows humor, that the Congress decided to allow people to put the money into an investment account ... at precisely the time when no one in their right mind would! With the stock market ... and everything else(!) in free fall, it is doubtful that provision will be of substantive value to anyone. Actually, I would guess that the vast majority of recipients will be able to "make" between 12% and 20% on their entire claim almost instantly ... by paying down the credit card balances they've had to let rise while waiting for their money from Exxon!




But thanks anyway Lisa.]




So, our hypothethical average fisherperson with a check from Exxon (as distributed by Keller Rohrback, the appointed Claims Administrators) in 2008 of $8,062 would still, in real life, most likely owe a fourth or so of that to Uncle Sam; meaning that they retain 3/4 of it. More math:




$8,062 x .75 = $6,046.




The small claims court limit in Alaska is $10,000. Anything below that is so little money in a court context that the PTB (powers that be) don't figure it is even worth hiring a lawyer for.




While we are having fun with math, let's take one last gander at something.




$6,046 / 20 = $302.




I know that we aren't quite at 20 years (the spill was in March), but we already have that much "range" into the numbers by now ... they are only rough averages at best. But ... if you take the average net award as we calculated it and spread it out over 20 years ... the big famous "terribly destructive of Big Business and Insurance Companies" punitive damage judgment works out to $302 per year for each plaintiff.




For probably the substantial majority of these folks, they've vastly more than $302 of value (fish not caught, interest payments on the replacement gear they had to buy, whatever) each and every year since the spill that was never recompensed in any way.




20 x 365 = 7,300, so




$6,046 /7300 = $.83.




Using rough numbers again, but just assuming 20 years at 365 days a year ... the net amount pocketed by the average claimant works out to less than .83 per day each day since the spill.




And they have the nerve to call that Justice???




It was headline news everywhere when the 1994 verdict came in and Exxon was docked $5 billion in punitive damages. Very few newspapers outside of Alaska paid it any further attention. And now, 20 years later ... the media has a "who cares/old news" attitude. The spill and the trial and verdict were sexy news stories. They got lots of attention.




Now, an entire generation has been born and graduated from high school since the spill. Many people don't know much about it, if anything. Most people were left with the impression that Exxon got spanked big time and huge amounts of $$ flowed into the desolate little "used to be" fishing villages.




If a newspaper mentioned the decision by the Supremes at all it was usually just a squib along with a bunch of other squibs about decisions handed down by the Supremes this year.




There should be public outrage. There should be marching in the streets. There should be protest signs. There should be long emailed-around-the-country petitions. There should be front page stories in the news magazines of the oiled beaches and birds and animals and fiery editorials calling on the country to be very scared at what precious rights were just flushed.




But none of that happened. It all ended with a whimper, not a bang.




Alaskans, particularly the hardiest of them: the trappers, small operation loggers, miners, and fishermen, are not the kind of people to need or want sympathy. Nor do they seek it out. So they aren't making a lot of noise. They mostly grumble into their beer and carry on. Rudyard Kipling in "If For Boys" described their stoicism well:




"If you can make one heap of all your winnings,
And risk it on one turn of pitch-and-toss,
And lose, and start again at your beginnings,
And never breathe a word about your loss;"



















Of course I always thought it was a terrible thing to teach kids that it was a good thing to gamble all they own on a roll of the dice ... :-)




There are some people making comments, but not very loudly and they aren't getting much press.




Frank Mullen is both a fisherman and an investment advisor. He hoped to make big bucks both from his claim and from helping other fisherment invest wisely. His reaction:




"Frank Mullen ... said he and other plaintiffs will certainly take the checks. But they won't be happy.




"It's a damn small bone for an old, angry dog is what it is," he said.




While $383 million is a lot of money and will be "a nice infusion for fishermen and communities," it's not much when divided among the 33,000 plaintiffs, he said.




And it won't inflict much pain on one of the world's richest corporations, Mullen said.




"It's a mere aggravation for a corporation as wealthy as they are," he said. "It's not at all likely to deter them from future environmental degradation."




Other Alaskans who care about the environment are in shock also. Interestingly, there are a surprising number of people (including myself) who have specifically noted that they were "ashamed" of the Court; which I take to be a powerfully good thing about our country and its system and its people. But it is stunts like this one that will make people no longer ashamed ... just disgusted with "business as usual". We're getting very close to that point and, once there, our entire system is in serious jeopardy. And when the house of cards that is our remarkable system of governance falls, it will be because of bought and paid for decisions like this one from a Court of which we all should be deeply ashamed.




Cindy Shogan of the Alaska Wilderness League said, "I'm ashamed at the Supreme Court, ashamed at this decision, and I'm just shocked that, once again, the oil industry wins."













Besides the actual earnings that never happened and the occupation itself and the (fascinating and unique) culture, perhaps the most important thing that I've seen people lose is ... their identity.

Folks who used to stride into fishermen meetings and state their opinions in the booming voices of confidence ... don't show up at the meetings any longer. Many are no longer Prince William Sound [PWS] fishermen. Few have starved. Some have gone to work for the oil companies or government. But there aren't many jobs in PWS outside the fishing industry and those who cater to it. Commuting to Anchorage is a pain. It is expensive. But worst is the loss of self-image.

Big, powerful, commercial fishermen who owned their own boats and gear and were their own bosses, lived in the wilds of Alaska and answered to no man ... became broken bitter shells commuting to 9 to 5 jobs to try to keep bread on the table. The bitterness was largely directed (appropriately) at Exxon (who proved exceedingly adept at rubbing salt in the wounds they created), but over time the bitterness spread until they became bitter at the whole world and ... most inappropriately ... at themselves.







"We Swore We'd Win and We Did - Even Better: You Lost".




Exxon has an attitude problem. Or, perhaps more accurately, much of the world has a problem with Exxon's attitude. It is not one of the Big Three ... no, not that Big Three ... the column on that issue will be coming along shortly. The Big Three oil companies doing business with Alaska: Connoco, Phillips and Tesoro ---


If the world hates a poor loser, it hates a bad winner even more. Though I've lost my share of battles in life without descent into the depths of opprobrium, I'm coming close to being a bad loser on this one. That said ... Exxon is such a bad winner that I won't even seem petty by comparison.

Of course when people lose a million dollars or more it generally isn't considered petty anyway. I don't know that my claim was ever worth anywhere close to that much. I did not have the damages that many others did. I do know that some claims were worth more than that however.


This was not a "judicial decision". Sad as it is to say this about our Supreme Court, this huge win by the anti-punitive damage crowd was a totally political ruling. I am not accusing the Justices of unethical behavior. I believe it is probable that they actually believe that punitive damages should be severely limited or abolished. But the Opinion issued by the Court was political in that Justices who believed in tort reform (curbing punitive damages) have been appointed to the courts largely on purely political considerations and the punitive damages issue was a major litmus test that has been employed by the Presidents who do the appointing.

By now, after many years of Republican Presidents appointing federal judges, the Federal Bench is filled with those appointees who no longer followed the law or the Constitution (even though they may believe that they do); and to a very large extent, promotion to higher courts is from within the system. You are much more likely to be appointed to a federal appellate court if you were a federal court trial judge ... and the same pattern generally holds with the Supreme Court.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~
February 15, 2009
Update

So much comes under the heading of "aftermath"! The spill had a greater effect on the State than most people have any conception.

I left this post unfinished as I had to move on to other things. But I promised to come back and "wrap up the aftermath"!



The court appointed administrators continue to dribble out pieces of payments. Why not do it all at once? It seems like it would make sense to just get it over with (!) especially since it is so much less money than they were set to disburse. But I suppose it is just as much hassle to write a check for $5 as it is for $500 and the claims are complex and convoluted. They started out that way ... ~33,000 plaintiffs of several different categories all with varying damages and individual situations that had to be accounted for in the distribution formulas.




But then wait 20 years. When Rip Van Exxon awoke he found that he was an old man and that many of his friends were dead and others had simply disappeared. Alaska is a transcient state. Lots of folks sort of float through here. Maybe stay a few years; have a grand adventure by working as a commercial fisherman in the cold and unforgiving waters of Alaska ... then wander on, or, as the responsibilities of real life beckon they pack up the pictures and diaries of their Alaskan adventure and go home to run the family store.




The "right kind" stay though. Alaskans self-select probably more than in any other state. Firstly because so much of its population is comprised of 1st generation immigrants but primarily because Alaska is so different from any other state. I think the only place I've heard the story more often about than Alaska is Hawaii, and at that it is probably about a toss-up ... but so many people come up for a vacation ... and then simply can't bring themselves to leave.




Others have had to sell parts of their claim at a dramatic discount just to survive. The buyers generally only bought the cream as they attempted to minimize risk. I've seen a bunch of such deals. Typically, the buyer only bought a small portion of the anticipated claim amount. If by rough numbers the claimant would have a $300,000 claim, the buyer would, for example, buy the "first $50,000" of it. That way, even if it was gutted far worse than anyone could reasonably believe ... the buyer would still be fine. Interestingly since the final result is so far from anything "reasonable", many claimants will end up with nothing and it will be nip and tuck as to whether the buyers even get their investments back!




Then of course there is the "unintentional" parting of the claims as child support enforcement, student loan programs, the I.R.S. and any other government department that believed the claimant owed money slapped liens on the payout. It is another interesting twist that some of these folks won't be getting paid off either. I don't know the mechanism, but I understand that a bunch of I.R.S. workouts, for example, were premised on the filing of liens on the Exxon payments. Now the I.R.S. is going to have to dig a lot harder to get their money out of people who owe it.




Others have judgments against them for bills they couldn't pay which will be offset against their payments. A lot of people won't get a dime ... people that lost their livelihoods ... and a 20 year fight for justice. And with a final spit in the eye they will actually receive a check made out in their names showing that it is the final Exxon payment ... for $0.00. They actually make the checks out that way. I'm sure there is a reason for it and I presume it is the Administrator's decision not Exxon's. But to me it just looks like an insult: adding insult to injury.




Many, many of the claimants have died. So their Estates must be reopened; which is beyond stupid, but par for this course. This is by far the biggest screwed up boondoggle that most of us will ever run into in our personal lives; even those of us whose lives are long since over. But, naturally, if there is an easy way or a messy blundering way ... we are going to find the most awkward possible way to proceed! Even those folks who were "with it" enough to have the probate assign the rights to the Exxon judgment ... which is a perfectly valid thing to do legally and works with any other sort of judgement, are being forced to reopen the probates. Some of those probates are 20 years old! Even the heirs are dead by now. This is one of those ripple effects. Now, whatever heirs of heirs are remaning alive must hire a lawyer and have the court system dig out 15 year old microfiche if they can find it, to reopen the propate, in order to get Grandpa's $3820.00 net claim amount (which was ~$169,000.00 when he died; happily thinking that he had at least left his wife and family in good shape because of the money that they would soon receive). In many cases it simply won't be worth it and others just won't get around to it or bother to do it. Many people don't even know who should do what if the primary heirs are also deceased. And many fishermen types are not very comfortable walking into a lawyer's office to deal with these sorts of matters.




I was contemplating and this interesting piece of trivia occurred to me: This year is the 20th anniversary of the Exxon spill ... and the 50th anniversary of statehood! It is beyond mind-boggling to me that such a huge portion of our "State's" history has occurred post Exxon spill.




But it emphasizes the point that we have been dealing with the "aftermath" for a very long time. We have talked in detail about what the spill and Exxon's reaction as it vies for the title of "Most Socially Irresponsible Corporation" ["MSIC]. Actually it is leading in several categories. They have been suffiently publicly exhuberant about the win they probably will take the "Rubbing Face In It" and have a real shot at the coveted "I Told You So" plaque. Frankly the adding insult to injury bit should make them a lock for the top 2008/2009 corpocracy awards. Not enough information has come to light yet. It is possible that the Halliburtan Iraq Contract will be in the running. Should be an interesting Awards Banquet in any event.




Insult to injury. That was ... after convincing the majority of the members of the Supreme Court that it should take the food away from the mouths of babies so that a corporate giant doesn't lose 6 days worth of profits ... and having the nerve to still call the remaining crumbs "punitive" damages. I'm sure Exxon really feels punished (which is ths purpose of punitive damage awards). If anyone has read this far without realizing that the previous sentence, before the parenthetical aside is pure unadulterated sarcasm, then I think you're on the wrong blog. Where were we? Oh yes, rubbing salt in the wound because they can ... after one of the greatest "wins" in Supreme Court history such that they got the punitive award knocked down to where they really can pay it out of the petty cash/annual party fund account ... they run back to court to try to convince them that there should be no interest on the award. Now that takes chutzpah! But what they have done to people and how they have used their incredible power and infinite patience to tell a jury to stuff it ... has been pretty well covered.




Aftermath. Yeah. The aftermath. Besides the destruction of the exemplary damages lawsuit ... which destroyed much, there is the "other" critical question. Indeed, if it weren't for our empathy towards fellow humans (and our culturally and personally entangled issues regarding money!) ... the damages done to the Sound are perhaps ultimately more important. What's left regarding the aftermath is perhaps the primary and most important ramification. How sound is the Sound? We've had 20 years. It must be pretty much back to pristine, huh? Not.







While it is true that most of the oil is ... gone (evaporated, sank, dissipated, soaked deeply into the sand and China is busy drilling it now, or other) ... that is far from unversal. One thing most people don't realize is how slowly natural "events occur up here in this land of nine months of ice and snow. A twenty year old spruce tree may look like something impressive in California (if well-watered!) Here it is a scrawny sapling barely large enough to use for a Christmas tree. If a tree falls in the forest does anyone hear it? Maybe. But it will still be lying there in 20 years where in Iowa it would have rotted back to humis/soil long ago. Environmental scars heal slower up here. Primarily that is because virtually no progress is made during the winter months. It is like in your own kitchen. You set the cream on the table. It is warm and comfy ... and curdles in about two days; stinks up the entire house by day 4 ... and is a semi-solid mass of spoiled "cheeze" in a week. Yet if you put the same cream in the refrigerator ... it's probably still "good" after that week. Alaska is the refrigerator. Processes that might have deteriorated and broken down the oil in California either don't work up here, or the work for so short a season each year that it takes an enormous amount of time for the land to recover from harms.


First, realize how large an area we are talking about. There are various estimates, but that is the Kenai Peninsula shown in the map and that's a large peninsula. It is difficult to put things into perspective with just a map, so look at it this way. The Kenai Peninsula is larger that ten (10!) It is larger than West Virginia! It is more than double the size of Maryland! And you could put Rhode Island and Delaware in one of the smaller bays and never notice it.


That, my friends, is the size of this oil spill, which, as you can see, due to uncooperative winds, tides and currents, mostly headed for the beaches rather than wander out to sea. There are various extimates for how much shoreline was oiled. But this is a good "middle of the road" estimate: "The great oil slick eventually drifted 500 miles, contaminating 1500 miles of shoreline covering an area 10,000 square miles. If you were to superimpose the length of the area covered by the spill onto the east coast of the U.S. it would stretch from Massachusetts to North Carolina."


Some of us aren't all that conversant in the areas of Massachusetts and North Carolina :-) So let's take the nation's third largest state (behind Alaska and Texas). It runs approximately 800 miles north to south and, I suppose by following the uneven shores, it has a coastline of approximately 840 miles. Again note the above section where is says that 1500 miles of Alaska's shoreline were contaminated by the spill covering an area of 10,000 miles.


Please pay attention here! :-) This is critical to understanding the magnitude of what we were dealing with. The Exxon-Valdez oil spill contaminated 1500 miles of Alaska's shoreline ... and California has a total shoreline of 840 miles. Look again at the map. That's not quite double the amount of shore that California even has! A bit more perspective ... the spill covered an area of 10,000 miles ... an area larger than six (6!) states! The entire state of Vermont is 9,615 square miles!


It is only because Alaska is so large that Exxon has been able to get away with a wave of the hand and talk of a "small percentage" of Alaska's coastline. Compared to anything except Alaska ... the spill was enormous!


And it was a critical 1500 miles of shoreline. That is a huge part of Alaska's ... uh ... fish basket! :-) Tremendous numbers of salmon, crab, shrimp, halibut and many other species were fished heavily, but sustainably. Now, there are some major eco-systems that may never recover and some fish and other marine life [eg: the sub-species of Killer Whale that roamed Prince William Sound] that will become extinct as a result of the spill. We not only can't fish the "at risk" sea creatures sustainably ... it is all we can do to try to keep them sustained without fishing them!


Nor did the oil go away.































Debate re: long term affects

Wildlife decimation







Cleanup etc.








14.12.08

Exxon: Pouring Oil on Troubled Waters

December 11, 2008
Exxon: Pouring Oil on Troubled Waters

-AKA-
Why Exactly Is It That They Call It "Good" Friday?

Alaskans are a bit leery of Good Friday. First of all, the Christians have never exactly explained what is so good about the day that Jesus was killed and buried. But more particularly in this State, we've come to be distrustful of the date of that occasion! Possibly the two most major disasters in recorded Alaskan history were the "Good Friday earthquake" of 1964 and the "Good Friday grounding of the Exxon Valdez" in 1989.

Which brings us to the "Big News" of the last few days for many folks around these parts. The first "micro-checks" started showing up from that semi-mythical creature known as the "Exxon claims". This is the first money fishermen have seen from the 1994 jury determination to punish Exxon for deciding to let a known-to-the-company drunk command a massive ship full of oil through tight narrows, ship-lane clogging icebergs, reefs, shoals and rocks, at night.

Unfortunately there are two problems with the funds (not actually checks yet) that are finally arriving. Well, three if you count the cause.

Problem 1: They are at least 15 years late in arriving;
Problem 2: They are at least a decimal place too small; and
Problem 3: They demonstrate that our system of justice has been sold to the highest bidder. And the American citizenry didn't win the bid.

The "Wreck of the Exxon Valdez" has been written about enough to begin to wonder if all the trees cut to make paper for the books, newspapers and magazines are adding substantively to the environmental damage caused by the "accident". That said:

"Critics ranked in serried rows,
Fill the enormous plaza full.
But there is only one who knows,
And that's the man who fights the bull."


Not many of the accounts are written by individuals who were [or would have been (!)] commercial fishermen in 1989 who were beached for the summer due to the oil spill.

I, however, am one of those fishermen.

Indeed, I'm fairly well connected with the fishing community. My father was an Alaskan commercial fisherman. My grandfather was an Alaskan commercial fisherman! [I'm one of very few people who has no Native blood that can make that claim; and one of a tiny handful of folks over the age of 50 that can! :-)] I was fishing (captaining) a "cannery boat" before I was of legal age to work most of the jobs in the cannery (and making vastly more money than my high school classmates who were working the brutally exhausting and wretchedly slimy cannery jobs and hating me! :-) My brothers, uncles, cousins ... and every other legal and illegal relationship possible, including my wife ... were (and/or are) commercial fisherfolk. I know a great number of the Exxon claimants. I know many of the lawyers who represented them. I am very well acquainted with the law. I have followed this fascinating debacle for two decades and been intimately involved in parts of it. I believe that I can shed light in places and on issues in ways it hasn't previously been shed. I can't think of anyone more qualified to write about it from my particular unique perspective than myself! :-)

And so I shall.

The Exxon-Valdez, a single-hulled [ie: cheaper] oil tanker, didn't make it that night (actually, slightly after midnight on the morning of) March 24, 1989. The so appropriately named tanker run and owned by Exxon was attempting to leave Valdez, a little town in Prince William Sound ("PWS") which was, the day before, one of the most beautiful, scenic and pristine bays in the world. It was not only an unfortunate place, but also an unfortunate date as it was only shortly before the commercial, sport and "guided sport" fishing seasons started in the Sound in earnest.

Captain "Slam Drunk" Hazelwood wasn't even on the bridge. He was already inebriated before the ship ever left harbor; having ("reasonably" if you are an Exxon lawyer) spent the time while it was being loaded doing the same to himself at two local bars. The report that he had ordered a double shot of "exxon on the rocks" has been widely discredited.

His crew and other Exxon employees finished loading the sloshing oil and the sloshed Captain on board without finding any problems worth reporting regarding either.
Yeah, yeah, they just wanted to keep their jobs and he was the Captain after all. As employees of the ultimate corporate bureaucratic behemoth no one wanted to, shall we say, "rock the boat". Exxon liked to keep problems quiet, follow the "chain of command", demand and reward "loyalty" as defined by the company, and already knew Hazelwood was a drunk. Why risk your job going over the lolling head of your Captain to report that he had to be poured aboard once again?

"Just following orders", the phrase and concept made famous in the Nuremberg trials, is as robust as ever. It seems to me that a "responsible corporate citizen", yet another multiply self-contradictory phrase, indeed in competition for oxymoronic fame, that Alice can add to her pre-breakfast belief menu, would perhaps terminate (aka: "fire") crew persons who failed report that the Captain was drunk, especially given the potential for horrendous damage if the vessel was not intelligently, even wisely, captained through the Sound. But that isn't the way Exxon works. I have little doubt that the "just keep our mouths shut and hope to hold onto the job until retirement" employees were absolutely correct that it was in their personal best interests to "look the other way" (and not listen or smell either) when the Captain was ... loaded, in several meanings of the word.

It destroyed ecosystems and habitat. It played destructive havoc with important renewable commercial fishing and harvesting resources. [In Alaska a huge percentage of our revenue comes from oil and we are not raising and killing any new dinosaurs; it is a critical value of the fishing industries that they are renewable. Properly managed ... and absent massive oil spills, the salmon and herring and other should continue returning and reproducing in vast quantities for the foreseeable future.]

Fisheries were closed as giant sheets of black oil spread like ink across the waters. For nearly three calm and peaceful days Exxon's [and soon the State's and anyone else's that could be found] cleanup crews, equipment and operations put floating booms around the ship to try to contain the oil while they held meetings. There were ideas and suggestions. "Burn it! Just toss a match over board!" ... "Bacteria are the answer. They can be designed and 'trained' to 'eat' oil!" ... "Chemicals are the only answer. Neutralize it, break it down, destroy it." and on and on until the seas stopped taking a holiday. Many "experts" from out-of-state didn't truly understand the wilds of the Alaskan ocean. The wind arose mightily pushing the floating oil through, over and under the booms like they were child's toys. It drove the oil to the sands and rocks of the shore.

"And that it was buried, and the waves rose again on the third day according to the scriptures."

Ok. So maybe the scriptures weren't involved. But it was becoming a disaster of Biblical proportions. Fishermen pulled crab pots full of black oily tar; and crabs that were covered in it. They pulled shrimp pots so tarred that the fishing boats that they carried them back to shore on were condemned ... the boats were too badly oiled to ever carry "foodstuffs" again. The salmon and herring fishermen looked at the waters where they would have, in so much the same way that Jesus's disciples did 2,000 years earlier, cast their nets ... and saw the waters covered with black oozing goo. The fisheries in the Sound were closed costing the communities that had little else in the way of income, their entire year's earnings. It would have been pointless to let them fish. The market for Alaska seafoods had disappeared overnight.


This "market effect" of the news of the spill did substantial economic damage to many fishermen far away from the oiled fishing areas; but they had no apparent "standing" to bring a claim against Exxon even though the effects of Exxon's actions harmed them greatly. Again, many of these folks lost their livelihoods --their businesses -- because of Exxon.

Fishing is always a a gamble; sometimes a great single day can bring substantial revenue (my Mom always claimed that commercial fishing ruined more good men than drink did :-), but mostly the margins are very tight and a single major event (such as the Exxon caused price crash) can "sink" the business. It is of note that Alaska salmon prices have never again approached the prices that they fetched before Exxon took the mystique out of "from Alaska's pristine waters". The state has even tried setting up its own marketing department to attempt to bring back the "image" of the "brand". But now, when people hear "Alaska wild salmon" the picture they conjure is as likely to be of black, oiled waters as it is of pristine nature.] Oh ... I must get in a plug for the fisherfolks' product! Many recent studies have shown that Alaska caught salmon are indeed clean and as toxin-free as any in the world and, overall, perhaps the healthiest fish you can eat (salmon oil is nearly a miracle drug).

It is possible to calculate some of those direct damages and make educated guesses as to how much money the fishermen lost that summer. But it was not, and still is not, possible to accurately determine the long-term effects of the destruction of habi
tat . Entire eco-systems crashed with unknowable results. One example out of hundreds; perhaps thousands: Murres are noisy, dirty, raucous birds that have never found a market value. There were, at the most optimistic, up to 350,000 in the area of PWS at the time of the spill. 16,600 were reported dead. "Reported dead" means that the bodies were actually recovered. Although the experts certainly all took their shots ... it is anyone's guess what percentage of the birds that died had bodies that were actually recovered. Some say the actual death rate should be calculated to be six times larger than the number of bodies recovered. Others said at least ten times. But no one knows. And no one knows how many died later because their food was killed, destroyed, removed ... or, in the spring when they fed their babies, poisoned.

What is the value of that devastation of the murre population? Exxon's lawyers say that in terms of financial damages ... the number is zero; and that therefore Exxon should not have to pay anything for having caused such widespread destruction.

Exxon did dump money into the (probably more harm than good) "cleanup" and in extremely modest "negotiated fines" from the State (
not much in comparison to the damages they did, according to the jury and essentially everyone who wasn't on the payroll of Exxon or some other mult
inational corporation). Even their insurance companies sued them claiming it was just a P.R. ploy! To this day the argument continues as to whether the cleanup did any good (beyond its obvious P.R. value which did Exxon potentially billions of dollars of good). Oiled rocks were laboriously washed by hand ... and then set back down on the beach beneath which .............~~~~~Scrubbing Rocks By Hand Foolishness~~~~~............. lurked huge piles of oil which surfaced randomly over the next couple of decades and is still doing so today. They used harsh chemicals which killed more of the life at the bottom of the food chain [which ultimately killed, and continues to kill, the life at the top of the food chain as well which included the "life of a fisherman in PWS"]. They used scalding hot water which killed corals and shellfish. No one knew what to do, or even who was "in charge", so no one knew who was to tell them what to tell them to do and what not to do ... the answers to which no one seemed to know in any event.
There are now salmon fisheries in the Sound although they can't be described as "recovered". The herring largely disappeared.

There has not been a shrimp season since the spill.

Nor does it seem, imho, that washing the oil back into the Sound with high pressure hoses would do the shrimp (or any other marine populations any good). And washing rocks by hand? Please! We didn't appreciate the insult to our intelligence. There were 1300 miles of oiled coastline! Let's see ... hire 1300 people, hand them a rag and some industrial strength cleaners and tell them to clean a mile of beach each. Well, at least the court case would have been resolved before the beach was cleaned! Oil, as any home mechanic is aware, is tough stuff to clean off! And Alaska crude ... the crudest, tarriest, ugliest of them all is a lot tougher than a spilled can of engine oil.

They may as well have put models in swimsuits out there it was so obviously for P.R. show!

It has never been easy to live the life of a fisherman in a small Alaskan fishing village. The hardships are tremendous. But the rewards of the lifestyle were of such a value that most people would never be able to experience or even understand. It is very difficult for, say, Supreme Court Justices who live in gated, gardened and guarded subdivisions and work in fancy air conditioned offices in the urban East to have any understanding of the value of this lifestyle for the people who (sometimes overcoming tremendous obstacles) have chosen it.

To be an Alaskan fisherman has such magnetic [it attracts men and women made of steel :-)] romance! It is a true dearly held dream of so very many people in the world. To be one of the last "free people" answerable to no one but your God if you have one and dependent upon no one and no thing except Nature, is such a rarity (and like so many dreams, not entirely accurate). But there is something magical about a life spent living off what nature provides; being among the last of the hunter/gatherers. Kids in cities watch the "Perfect Storm" and read about green, untrained deck hands on the boats of crab fishermen who, because they have to risk that sort of thrilling danger (and because the King Crab is such an expensive delicacy) can make $30,000 or more in a college summer vacation ... and look out the window at the soot-stained dirty gray of the city and dream the age-old dream. Few of course succeed at making their dream live. It is a long trip from New York desk jockey to Kodiak fisherman and I'm not referring to miles. Those that make it are the ones to whom its value is incalculable.


Pinned to my wall I have a small yellowed newspaper clipping. I don't know who wrote it. I do remember that the article was about the unique possiblities of the Last Frontier:

"The trapper, the miner, the commercial fishermen -- are free agents -- they dictate their own hours, direct their own labors, and when it suits them, tell people to go to hell."

To be part of that ... probably very close to the last generation for whom such is even possible means the difference between a life lived and an existence endured for many more than achieve it. It is not an easy lifestyle! Besides the backbreaking hard physical work, one must pay a substantial amount of money to get into the business. You must buy a boat or beach-site, fishing gear including nets, skiffs (on the beach, the boats they use to pick fish from are called "dories"), a fisheries permit for the fishery you wish to participate in [some permits for some fisheries sold for nearly $1 million before the spill!]. And on a bad year ... when the fish don't show or the weather was too bad to fish during the very short "height" of the run or the Fish and Game closes the fishery at the wrong time based on poor data or the boat didn't start on the "big day" (sometimes an entire season comes down to a single one-day "period" where you might make half of your income for the entire summer) or you ran it onto a sand bar through stupidity and lack of sleep when leaving the harbor at 3 a.m. or any number of other possible "things that can go wrong"... you don't make any money. It was a major struggle to "make it" in that life before the spill. Afterwards, in many parts of the state, it largely became impossible.

With no income, many fisherfolk who valued their rugged independent lifestyle had to move to the city, to Anchorage, and take desk jobs to survive. Some left the State where they were born and/or planned on living out the remainder of their lives. Some, in a personal shame that will haunt them all their lives and that the beggers of Telegraph Avenue would be incapable of comprehending, accepted handouts. First from churches and charities, later ... foodstamps and welfare. And they broke inside. And their children watch them break inside. Something far more valuable than money was lost that summer.

Yet money was the only thing the courts or anyone else could offer in exchange for what had been so rudely and stupidly taken by the foul recklessness of an oil company that simply didn't care enough to take the most basic precautions; and a captain who found the contents of a pint bottle far more important than 200,000 tons of oil.

It took Exxon nearly 20 years. Two decades of constant effort. But they succeeded at ensuring that not only did they not replace the irreplaceable. But they ensured that they wouldn't have to pay the people whose livelihood ... whose pristine thousands of miles of "front yard" had been destroyed ... any substantive amounts of money as punishment for their actions. Could a giant international globalist corporation that earned net profits of over $5 billion a year [now, 20 years later, closer to $5 billion a month] buy "justice" ... or would America and its wonderful long history of an independent court system that treats the rich and poor alike prevail?

It took 20 years. But at last, we now have the answer.

Part 2 of This Series May be Viewed Here: